I've used just about every "traditional" screen protector out there and all claimed they "feel like glass", and I never thought that.
The day I saw the Tech Armor Ballistic glass on sale for $15, I got it. It feels exactly like the glass you're protecting since it is glass after all. The ONLY knock I have on it is that the physical button becomes sinked in due to the added glass, but I did get used to it and I can find the physical button easier in the dark. I mean it wasn't really hard to find in the first place, but not it's impossible to miss
I'd recommend you try it. If you don't like it, their customer service is excellent and they'll refund you without any hassle.