For those of you wondering, I bought the incipio case.
Yes, it's thinner than the clear plastic case Verizon sent me home with, but not by much.
It looked nice, the back plate fits great. The front plate had a little give to it but it isn't designed especially well. It didn't immediately snap on, I had to work it a little bit. All sides are manufactured equally, so it goes on whichever way you'd like. Unfortunately, that also means when you slide open the keyboard, you can feel one side rub the keys and, unlike other plastic snapons, it doesn't have a thinner bevel at the bottom to allow for easy access to the front buttons. You can get them, they're not covered, but it feels like you're only able to touch the top 2/3s of the button.
However, one drop was all it took to break it. Not an exceptionally long drop (It wasn't out a window or anything) just from the kitchen counter to the floor and snapped the front plate. I could probably glue it but since it didn't fit especially well to begin with, it's not worth it.
I will give Incipio credit, I placed the order on the 14th and it was at my house on the 17th (shipped from CA to NC).
Not the case I was looking for. Oh well.
**EDIT** I just posted the same review on Incipio's site and it is 'pending review.' Take that for what it's worth, but there are currently 0 reviews of these cases posted.