I love the debate these threads bring. When I started this thread I had been back and forth between Bionic and Thunderbolt. After reading some of the replies of the dedicated Motorola device enthusiasts, I decided to wait and do some more research.
Ive read tons and tons of threads from the DX, D2, and D2G. There are so many pi$$ed off individuals because of some of Motorola's practices.
- The bootloaders being locked down I'd say is the biggest. Even worse is their persistence on doing so. Yes, there are custom roms, but nowhere near as custom as for phones that aren't as locked down. If you can't even change the kernel, you're really limited with customizations and performance enhancements. Instead you're stuck waiting for Motorola to push updates which may or may not come because they want you to buy their next locked down phone.
- Motorola recently got the GRD website shut down for "copyright infringement". Apparently they had some copyrighted D2G pics posted which I understand may have been legit, but looking at Moto's recent track record I must wonder if there's more reasons behind it. They even had the developers PayPal account frozen!
- In official statements on their own website, they basically said if you want to rom, buy someone else's devices. Wow...
- Verizon recently rejected the gb update for the DX I believe it was? I don't know details, but i'm not surprised. If I'm wrong on this one (as i may be), please chime in.
The Bionic may be awesome when it's released, but Motorola is certainly looking far from stellar to me. As much as i would like the phone, I don't think think I would like the whole "closed open source" experience. They must have gotten their hands on the Apple playbook. I don't think i'll ever buy Apple, and sorry to say, probably not another Motorola device either. Unless that is, they change their bootloader policy which they seem quite devoted to. It's a shame, they hit the ball out of the park with the D1...
I'm sure there will be many who disagree with me, an many who agree too. If you think I've misrepresented the facts or gotten them confused, please chime in.