Because ethics needs to start somehwere thats why..
If you choose to be unethical and immoral so be it.
I do not and I will stand my ground.
The OP believed his Otterbox caused a problem with his phone. Several others offered opinions to the contrary. That's what this forum is about -- to exchange ideas regarding what really may be causing problems. Hopefully solutions are offered as well. There is no ethical or moral issue here IMO.
Note: I am not advocating free speech here, where you can post anything you want, as those rights to do so do not apply on this or any other privately owned message board. But that's a totally different discussion.
Full disclosure: Former Admin on another (non-Android) site. Both my wife and I have the Otterbox Commuter on our phones and neither of us are experiencing any major issues, with or without them.