Being it was with in the 14 days they should have given you a new one, once the 14 days are past then they could go refurb. Is your refurb phone working okay at least?
New phone works fine and you can't tell it from new however it did have a "factory new refurb" sticker on it. I went to the Verizon Store in the next town over and they did not give me one that day but instead said they had to ship me one. Two days later Fedex delivered the phone and it was a refurb.