Just got mine today! I shipped it free (USPS) and ordered it on Sunday night, got an order confirmation Monday morning, and the case arrived today. I like it so far, seems durable (like all otterbox products, but because the sliding keyboard, it does not envelop the entire droid, but provides protection (i.e. water can still leak in between the screen and the keyboard). There is a rubber gasket around the bottom 1/2 of the droid (keyboard area) to reduce this, but still.... As for the top piece, it is really just a click on piece of plastic that goes over a screen protector (clear). I have my original screen protector on underneath otterbox's harder plastic, and the Droid seems to take my inputs just as nicely as if the hard plastic protective screen were not present. They also keep the speaker uncovered (another possible source of water leaking into the droid, but the sound is still clear, so this is a trade-off). I have not tried this with my docking station yet, and because of the case, I do not think that the car-dock will work either unless you remove the bottom 1/2 of the otterbox case.
All in all, I would rate this case an 8 out of 10.
Cheers,
B.D.
