We have absolutely zero concrete info on the specs for either of the new Moto Droids, nor do we have even one absolutely for sure picture of of either phone in it's final production state. Even the Verizon inventory pics could easily be faked.
We know nothing for sure at this point. Asuming we do have correct info, and since I don't hardly ever use the physical keyboard, I am leaning towards the Xtreme more than the Droid 2, but we have to keep in mind that we may be getting 'fed' this info to throw us (and the rest of the industry) off.