Wow, I think my joke/comment back in 2011 sounds pretty harsh today -- I wonder if the playing field has evened out a lot in 2 years. Sadly, I still lack any meaningful experience with an iPhone, and the next best claim I can make is that I set up my daughter's 4th gen iPod Touch. But while doing so, I found myself thinking two things...first, "where's the app tray?...wait...ALL THEIR APPS are on the homescreen???" and second, "Hmmm, not much opportunity to use the homescreen creatively." The take-away message is that I prefer the Android experience through and through, and yeah, I do kinda think our team has caught up in usability and maybe then some.
If a prospective owner says "it's too hard," forgive me for thinking this, but hey if I can get my gadget-unfriendly wife to do anything and everything she wants to on her Moto X and Nexus 7, then I don't think the problem is with the OS or the user interface.
-Matt