Third time through because you failed to clearly explain yourself the first two times. Still you remain vague.
These standards are to be applied to replacement devices VZW is giving to a customer?
... so where does the $299 fee come in?
See where you're leaving out critical information?
The fee is charged if you send in a device that has damage not covered by the warranty. What is vague about that?
Cracked or chipped screen? Charge
Cracked or dented housing? Charge
Moisture in the phone? Charge
Scratched paint? No charge
This is what happens when people trust "leaked" information.
Sent from my DROIDX
A warranty replacement (free) means there was/is something wrong with the device from the manufacturers standpoint. No?
So if these standards are being applied to the device being warrantied that's crap.
and the summary says scratches are reason to charge... last I knew a scratch can be considered a flaw. Why else would there be a measured requirement?
CLNR Cosmetic Standard Summary:
No blemishes are permitted on front surfaces such as the touch screen, keyboard
No more than two flaws, which must be less than 5mm in length, are permitted on other surfaces
No flaws or defects on lens
No dust, dirt, or fibers under lens
Ports must be free of foreign material and corrosion, be in operating condition, and have the plugs in place if applicable