I agree with you 100%...that was not my intention. He did nothing illegal by rooting his phone and rooting most likely didn't cause the problem. Returning the phone, if he doesn't pursue FoxKats process of trying to recover the phone which is where I was going in the first place, doesn't constitute fraud. If he had purchased insurance and stated he was submitting an insurance claim for something not allowed (rooting) under that coverage then he would be committing insurance fraud. In this case if Verizon discovers the phone to be rooted...and they will if they try to recover the phone, then they will determine he voided the warranty and the OP will most likely be getting a bill for repairs.
JP, I don't think that Vulcan's reply was directed at you. There was another member who made a comment that was subsequently deleted and before your comment, which in effect suggested fraud. I believe Vulcan's response was toward that member and anyone else considering such.
I agree that rooting didn't likely cause the issues he's experiencing, and even flashing a custom ROM may not be the cause, but now that the "leaked .215" ROM is on the phone and he can't get it to boot in order to flash it back to stock, he's risking the phone booting for the technicians, seeing it has an unofficial ROM and then suffering the repair bill.
Quote "It's rooted and flashed to the leaked 215 version".