Ha. This is funny. I thought I was the only one still holding on to an OG Droid. I've really enjoyed it but the battery life sucks and it's just time for a new toy.
Well, if you say you don't use 4G a lot (you're not in a good 4G coverage area), I am not sure if it matters if you are grandfathered into the unlimited thing or not. I am a fairly heavy user and I don't think I have ever gone over 1.5 gigs in a month. I came from a Droid 1 as well.
The Rezound has worked well for me...with the extended battery, I can do 14 hours easy, and I use my phone a lot. The Rezound has the best GPS reception on any phone I have used so far. Google maps flies on this thing. It has both SD and removable battery. 64 gig SD cards have been confirmed to work with it. It has an awesome camera and true 720p display. HTC allows you to unlock your phone "legitimately" now, and there is a great ROM community for it. I am running a leaked version of ICS, and this phone is pretty damn near perfect IMO now. ICS is just liquid smooth on this thing, even running stock. If it matters, it is also a world phone, and has the best voice reception of any phone I have used so far.
The Galaxy S3 is another good phone coming out shortly. It has everything the Rezound has but better (except maybe the display, but that is mostly personal preference). It also has NFC. The American version won't have a quad core CPU but it will have the S4, which is still awesome. According to Droid Life, you can still be grandfathered into unlimited data and get this phone (-
Pre-order the Galaxy SIII From Verizon and You Keep Your Unlimited Data Plan – Droid Life -). Also has an awesome camera, probably even better than the Rezound.
Ditto with the Incredible 4G...It has everything the Rezound does except a better CPU (S4) and a slightly worse display (qHD). It also has NFC I think. We are getting this on Verizon instead of the HTC One X. It is tiny compared to the others, but bigger than the Droid 1 I think.
If I was going to buy a phone from Verizon right now, it'd be one of those three. I'd pass on the Razr (Moto are assholes about rooting, and no removable battery and no 720p display), and I'd pass on the Nexus (The Galaxy S3 is better in every way, and the Nexus has no SD and ****ty phone reception). The only thing the Nexus has going for it is Vanilla Android.
Comparison:
Comparison: Galaxy S3 vs. Incredible 4G LTE vs. Galaxy Nexus vs. RAZR MAXX – Droid Life