I think you're highlighting a crucial point, and it probably explains differences in expectations/predictions. I've been assuming since Google bought Motorola Mobility that (a) Google would really take over the cell-phone division (e.g., Larry Page on August 15, 2011, "We will run Motorola as a separate business."), and (b) the Motorola of days past would cease to exist. (Disclaimer: I probably took Page's comment a bit out of context -- I'm putting the emphasis on "run" but Page put it on "separate," i.e., that running MM wouldn't influence Google's business model, Android would stay open, etc.).
Anyway, I really can't say if my assumption was totally ignorant and naive, or on the money, but so far I've looked at quotes like "we have to get the old phones out of the pipeline" to mean that once old inventory was sold off, Google would come in and "do their magic." I'm still (ignorantly?) hopeful that we'll see that transformation, and that if the X doesn't wow us enough, the next generation will certainly do a better job.
On a distantly-related note: it's also been hinted here a few times and I totally agree that Google's long-term vision is to merge cell phones and Glasses -- I'm assuming in 2-3 years the cell phones we carry around will be more like portable CPUs that mostly gather ambient data from multiple sensors, do a bit of local computing, but typically feed the data back into the cloud and then bring the "answers" back, e.g.,
User: Hey Google, do you recognize that red car over there?
GoogleChipPlantedInYourHead: It's a 2009 Ferrari.
User: How much does it cost?
GCPIYH: About $150,000 in good condition.
User: Wow, pretty expensive.
GCPIYH: Would you like to see something less expensive?
User: Naah...I'm kind of hungry. Is there a pizza place nearby?...
-Matt
Yeah ill pass on the Motorola X chip . But you make a good point about inventory and something I forgot about/overlooked. Motorola could be under contract (or agreement) to set carriers (particularly vzw) which promises to produce X amount of devices that meets a certain standard. This could hinder Google from what they can do. Remember a few years ago fans hammered Motorola about the locked bootloader and Motorola's response was that they had to design the software to the carrier's specs. At the time many called hogwash (me included) only to find out Motorola was right as we started seeing other oems lock down their devices. We saw how vzw treated the nexus where they wouldn't allow Google wallet and with what Google has planned for wallet there is no way they are going to continue to let that fly. When Google bought Motorola they also bought their contracts and they are obligated to honor it. So that makes since that Google has to wait to empty the pipeline to do what they have planned. With that said I do not see Google being quiet. The tech industry is a fast moving business move too late and it could be game over. So I expect the pipeline phones to make its way to the carriers but I also see them releasing devices that follow in the suit of Google experience where they release it for purchase on their play store (gsm/hspa/lte). At least I hope they do.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I317 using Tapatalk 4 Beta