I would go to a VZW store and compare your phone side by side with a display nexus or make them take one out of the box. Check both phones dBm and see what you get, if your phone is worse, swap it out. If its the same, decide if poor 3g reception is reason enough to drop the phone and go with something else. Also, you sure you are not being throttled on your Nexus? Have you tried switching the radio on the nexus to CDMA only and running the test again? I would switch it, reboot, and run the test again just to see what happens.
I wouldn't do any type of testing at a VZ store.
they always have a mobile 4G hotspot running in back and you'll see no real comparison.
I really think it's a low signal handling issue, and if you are in a fringe area it gets worse.
I posted in the other thread how I got mine just before the last outage, but after that came back up I saw some improvement, could actually get 4G upstairs in some locations in the house, whereas before I could not (and didnt expect to knowing I'm 4-5 miles away from the nearest 4G tower in the area).
But it does annoy the heck out of me that even if they think changing the display which is refelcting real sig strength is a fix, when you still know that your old OG on 3G was always pulling a good signal and was useful, yet the Nexus 3G radio is seriously lacking.
I don't care about bars, I'm tired of seeing the data indicator go away ... It shouldn't be happening in a known great 3G area. It means something isn't right, and kinda infuriates me that they can test out these units without noticing this at all. The testers should be canned.
I also think about those who say that Samsung can't make a good enough radio to use in the US. This is not rocket science, I'm sure the network specifications for use are spelled out somewhere for these manufacturers, if it wasn;t meeting spec, then why accept the design? It also had to go past FCC, I wonder in what reguard they enforce network spec compliance? (One would figure they look at it, you can't have it spilling outside it's alooted band for example ....)
I love my Nex, I just want it to work ...