I remember a guy bragging about having more than 60 doors on the way, and said to watch for them on eBay. I ordered mine free on through Motorola. It sits super snug but the top near the camera is not flush and somewhat loose, and also leaves a small gap, which almost everyone else is experiencing with the new doors. It is one problem or another, wish they would just spend a couple more bucks and make a damn door that fit precisely.
Well, I just put the new door on and if I see what I think you're complaining about then I got to be honest with you. You're being too picky.
The only difference I really see is that the new door doesn't have Verizon on it. They both had a little plate on the inside, didn't see much difference there.
I never had a problem with the battery door so maybe I had a good one to start with.
Edit: It does say Verizon on the back of the door. So I don't see any difference what so ever.