People buy things they can't
really afford all the time
Yeah, Homes, cars, boats, businesses. Less than 0.1% have enough cash to replace those items. Are you saying you wouldn't keep insurance on them?
You obviously didn't read all of my post. Of course you insure your home, car, truck, boat, business, life, medical etc.
Less expensive items like appliances, TV, phones, etc should not be. It isn't an uncommon line of thought for many
Your TV, appliances, etc., are probably insured under your homeowners policy; mine are. (Not extended warranties, but in case of accident, theft, fire, etc.) I carry replacement insurance on the phone since my phone is on my belt, and even though it is in a protective Seidio case, it is still subjected to an environment most will never see. On average, I replace the case at least once a year from it banging against a double Kydex mag holder.
One minute I could be standing around or sitting in a vehicle, and the next minute rolling on the ground trying to restrain someone. So, yes, in my case I find the replacement insurance worth the price. And, I can afford to replace the phone if I wanted too. But then again, I could self-insure my vehicle (replacement, not liability), but I don't.
I actually expect to replace at least one phone per year. If I don't I have spent approximately $72.00 to cover the insurance for that just in case happening.
So, what is right for one, is not necessarily right for another.