Can't say I've formed a complete opinion yet as there are a few things I'm trying to still figure out. For instance, I'm looking for the setting that allows the screen to stay on while using the map feature (I drive 37 miles one way to work and I use it to see where the traffic is). On the Moto Droid, no settings were needed. When I plugged it in, it stayed on. No questions. On the Incredible, it keeps dimming and then shutting off the screen. May not be a deal breaker to some, but since I use it 5 days a week on a 75 mile round trip, yeah, it makes a difference to me and it's annoying as all hell if I'm plugged in.
I'm going to use it on a trip starting Monday from Florida to Knoxville, TN, so I can give more details as I will really use it in depth then. One week hasn't been enough in my book.
What I will say now is that it is FAST. From installing programs to uploading data to even using it on wi-fi, it's just a faster device. I loaded all of the exact same programs on to the phone except for the Moto Flashlight (as that's a Moto Droid specific proggy). I did this via Appbrain.com which made it a piece of cake. Helps having the additional memory too. But as I posted earlier, faster isn't always better and there are some other trivial items that are making me long for the Droid 2 or whatever it will be called. Plus, I really do miss the keyboard. My typing has slowed on longer emails/text responses, so I will enjoy having that back eventually.
I'll give you more info as I progress.