Ok here's mine:
Screen: Great, on full brightness this thing looks amazing, great colors, deep blacks and no screendoor effect
Camera: More then adequate for a cellphone, couple of pictures I took came out just fine, so unless you're super picky you'll enjoy the cam
Feel: Doesn't feel as flimsy as many of us may have thought, battery door sucks though, it feels cheap as hell and feels like it's going to snap in half when you take it off
Smoothness: Very smooth for the most part, there is very very minimal stutter/lag when scrolling through big lists like Contacts or texts if you have a ton, but not a deal breaker at all and if you're coming from the D1 it's night and day
Easy to root? Yes, extremely. When I rooted my D1 for the first time two years ago, it was a confusing mess of commands, this time it was two commands for a fully rooted unlocked phone.
Battery: Obviously it's only the first day, but I did charge it fully before really playing with it. I didn't do anything too intensive, couple of texts, set up my screens, check Netflix (for like 10 seconds), and scroll around in there. Went down to 50% relatively quickly, so the extended battery might be something to consider, although I don't know how much of a difference it'll make. For me its no biggie, as I'm always near a charger, and I'm not worried about it dying while I'm on the road because I won't be using it as much and it'll definitely last a good while.
Face Unlock: It works and it works well. The only time it doesn't work is if it's dark and that's to be expected. With adequate lighting I had no issues at all.
People App: I like this thing for some reason, just think it was very nicely done. My only gripe is how the pics are all pixelated in the contact pages, so you'd have to get some super high res pics to really make it stand out
Call Screen: I like the full screen caller ID, but again the pixelated pics take away from it...once I load up some high res pics I'm sure it'll be fine
Apps: All my apps worked fine, haven't run into any issues, but I don't have a crapload of apps to begin with so some of you may run into issues if you download every app under the sun.
Keyboard: Meh, switched it out for Swiftkey. I woulda done Swype but the installer says they don't support this screen size. So not sure if I did something wrong, or if Swype has to update their keyboard for ICS.
4G: I live in the middle of nowhere now, so can't really comment on it. But I'm always back and forth between Miami and the Bronx so I'm sure the phone will be just fine browsing speed-wise
Browser: Great. I don't know if its the placebo affect, or the fact that I had a D1 where the browser would freeze for 20 minutes just to get to google.com, but browsing is enjoyable again. Super fast page loading even on 3G, faster on wifi obviously, and no checkerboarding or anything. Pinch to zoom is smooth.
Speakers/Volume: Too low. Vibrate is very soft also. Coming from a D1 which sounds like a herd of elephants compared to this phone I was a little disappointed, but whatever, I'm usually on vibrate anyway and I guess that'll have to do. Not going to return the phone because of that.
Not having to constantly watch memory and close out apps: priceless. It's great not having to worry about missing texts or voicemails because Handcent or Google Voice were shut down to reclaim memory. I have about 10 apps running and still have 250MB of memory free, and switching between the apps is fluid and quick and actually takes me to where I left the app, unlike the D1 where the app would be restarted every time I clicked it again
All in all, the phone is great...I have no intention to load up any ROMs on this phone as stock performs just fine and don't need any unnecessary features like gesture unlock or whatever else. I rooted for apps like light flow and root explorer, and I will probably do some theming to change some of the icons and apps around but other then that, the phone is a winner.
