Got my D2 today after 6 refurb D1s that were not up to snuff - various things (couple had repeated lock ups, couple wouldn't charge battery, one had a camera lens that wasn't fully seated and a small scratch on the top edge, last one dropped calls and screen jittered up and down when plugged in and scrolling on a screen.
Definitely not new or even like-new devices...QA on VZW/Moto side seems troubled.
I got a new D2 in a refurb box, chassis only, and battery cover and battery are coming in a separate shipment. Mine was not a surprise D2 that just showed up when I was waiting for a refurb, I had to talk to a couple supervisors to get them to send me a D2 after all my trouble w/D1 refurbs.
D2 seems good so far overall...mostly find things better overall than D1 - only thing I'm missing is running a custom ROM. Never OC'd over 1Ghz on my D1, so speed will be fine if they don't unlock the boot loader for custom kernels.