I have the BodyGlove case, and I love the fit...however, there are 2 MAJOR issues with it.
1. You can't fit it into any dock or mm station.
2. If you plan on taking pictures, the case gets in the way...the flash creates a nasty haze from the rubberized hole that is on the back, and the clip actually gets in the way if you don't remove it first!
These issues should be non-existent.
I wouldn't call not fitting into any dock or mm station a major flaw. Most cases that stay on the phone at all times don't fit in a dock. It's the nature of the beast.
Though you have a point, it IS a MAJOR FLAW. If you read this thread, there are a number of complaints about this. I purchased my Body Glove when I got the phone and loved the feel of the case, and it has definitely protected it against several drops, though my battery flies out when it happens. I went to Verizon and bought the car mount and mm station, then realized it was going to be a pain in the ass. I am now looking hard at Innocase, as they have compatible case/dock/mount combination. Someone was thinking when they put this stuff together. What I'm not seeing, however, in the Innocase Surface case, is a way to attach to the hip? I'd prefer that rather than a pocket, as I don't really have pockets. Would also like to see a mount for my Harley, now that would be nice...
My Body Glove has finally bit the dust. Back side vs. front, amazingly enough. Gave the front side to my girlfriend (whose front side broke weeks ago), and I'm naked. Time for a new case... Like I say, I like the looks of the Innocase product line, but also looking at the Otterbox, as it looks nice too.