What do you guys think about their opinions? I still have until the 15th to decide.
Agree with other comments on the battery. My OG battery was relatively abused and still has great charge. Before a smartphone, my last two dumbphones (and I don't run a lot of minutes) both had batteries about shot right around the 20 month upgrade window. But I think the new batteries should do better than 1-1.5 years. Maybe it's an issue with the RAZR if you plan to have it longer than 2 years, and maybe it's an issue if and when for flashing (I did have to do a number of battery pulls on my OG because of instability fiddling with roms).
As for ICS, the RAZR will be getting it sooner rather than later. I don't think that's really a valid reason beyond a month or two. If you run an alternate launcher, it's less of an issue. Yeah, ICS is faster and better optimized, but we're still waiting for many apps to catch-up.