I say let's both contact corporate... I know I went to a corporate store, and it sounds like you did too, so when a CS Supervisor GUARANTEES a "Brand New In Box" phone as a replacement, specifically a "BNIB Galaxy Nexus, not a Certified Like New Replacement", he is speaking for the company... The same company that owns the store!
The same store that kept offering me empty promises of a "fix", but as soon as my 30-Holiday-Warranty was up they won't give me the time of day!
How many other companies do you know that would treat someone like this, 5-7 weeks after spending $300 cash and signing a 2yr contract, and already having been a customer for TWELVE YEARS? Not just a customer, but someone whose plan includes five phones, unlimited minutes, unlimited text, and unlimited MMS on each, as well as Unlimited Data plans on 3/5? IT IS A LOT OF MONEY!
I even told the guy at the store (perhaps untruthfully) that ATT, Sprint, and T-Mobile had ALL offered to BUY OUT my contract from Verizon (it was true 3 years ago...), and based on my 12yr history of staying with one company had offered me 3mo FREE SERVICE identical to what I was getting from Verizon (unlimited everything), they would Guarantee For Life "Unlimited Data, regardless of form, on all phones under ******'s account, beginning immediately and will remain in effect (with no throttling) INDEFINITELY, regardless of corporate/company policy changes"... On top of that, two of the three offered me 5 free "Top-of-the-Line" Smartphones, while the other offered me $200 towards a new phone, per number, every 18mo for the next 12 years...
Seriously. I turned it down, because 3yrs ago, they all pretty much sucked.
I still have the unsigned contracts around here somewhere, and I do know that they DO NOT have any expiration date! I wonder what VZW would say if I walked in with them?
Anyway, I don't want to make threats that I don't yet want to follow through with. It's really ironic, because I have the best phone available in North America, and up until I got the phone I was 99% satisfied with Verizon... Now that I have this phone, Verizon has taken a nosedive in customer service quality.
I am going to call and call and call tomorrow and Monday, until I get someone to do something that works for me: either a refund for the entire MSRP of the phone (not what I paid, I mean the whole $700), a BRAND NEW replacement shipped to me under the condition that my current phone doesn't have to be postmarked for shipping until until AT LEAST 10 days after receiving the new unit, FREE UNLIMITED DATA for the duration of my new contract since they sh*tty service only lets me use it half the time (without losing the grandfathered-in Unltd Data paid), or $700 credit towards my billing cycle.
I will tell them that if ONE MORE PERSON tells me "Well, we can give you a BRAND NEW RAZOR MAXX, but sorry, no Galaxy Nexus", that I will contact Samsung, VZW Corporate, and the Better Business Bureau immediately.
I am normally a person who avoids conflict, but I consider it only right to fight back when someone is bending me over like this...