Oooh goodie! FRESH MEAT! You may be the exception to the generalizations I am making, we'll see. The majority though fit perfectly into my stereotypical iPhone owner.
I didn't need a physical keyboard. I had grown accustomed to typing with the virtual keyboard. So my options were immediately narrowed to the iPhone, Droid X, Droid Incredible, and Fascinate. The EVO was not an option as Sprint was not an acceptable carrier for me. Previous bad experience.
Size is an issue. The Droid X is too big for my hands (I'm only 5'6".) It felt awkward holding, and it was a bit of a stretch hitting the keys in the middle of the keyboard while in landscape mode.
Battery life was the next most important consideration. I rely heavily on push e-mail from my company's exchange server. I text like crazy, and when I'm sitting at my desk prepping tax returns, I have earbuds in playing music. I need a device that can comfortably go the distance. Given all the complaints I've seen on this forum regarding the Incredible, that made it an easy disqualification.
So I took to the Google with my focus narrowed to the Fascinate and the iPhone. Over at GSM Arena, there are two articles on the
iPhone and
Fascinate. The iPhone cruised in the continuous video play, but the simulated real word tests suggested the fascinate was almost a full 24 hours more of battery usage. But the tests aren't that similar. The iPhone was used for 40 minutes of gaming versus 30 minutes of GPS, and an extra hour of browsing and pictures over the Fascinate. Furthermore neither tested push Exchange, and my biggest complaint with Android is the e-mail client is stupidly inefficient at it. My Droid repeated took a pounding with 10-13% of battery usage during the day going just to the e-mail client. K-9 mail never worked for me, and TouchDown is too frickin expensive, especially for something that should be supported out of the box. Suffice to say, I gave the battery metrics a wash.
Hardware-wise, I couldn't reproduce the death grip on the model I held in the store, but had done it previously on a friend's phone who got his the week they came out. Antennagate was no issue for me since I couldn't re-produce it anymore, I don't need a removable battery, and neither phone looks more stylish than the other.
Software then became the next measure for me. I bank with Chase, and they don't have an Android app. They've got a pretty nice one for the iPhone though. In the limited in-store time I had with the iPhone before purchasing it, the apps I tried on the iPhone were far and away much higher quality than the Android equivalent. ESPN ScoreCenter blows SportsTap out of the water, multi touch (especially pinch and zoom in the browser) was far more fluid on the iPhone. I've had a couple of iPods throughout the years, so I've got a pretty good size iTunes library that I've built up, and since that's been my media play for some time now, it's simply so much easier to sync it with an iPhone. I bought iSyncr, but found it to be annoyingly tedious to use. Download the app, have it save the .exe to my SD card, plug in the phone, mount the SD, launch the exe, then tell it to sync everything.
But most importantly: the walled garden is a better fit for me than the haphazard, laissez faire Android market. I don't have to worry checking permissions on an app before installing it. A lot of the information that comes through my corporate e-mail is personal and confidential information from my clients such as EINs for their partnerships, S and C corps, and social security numbers. It's a huge security risk for me. The walled garden helps me protect not only myself but my clients as well.