What's new
DroidForums.net | Android Forum & News

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

P3Droid: Some Food for Thought - Bootloaders, Rooting, Manufacturers, and Carriers

Status
Not open for further replies.
Just my thoughts...don't see how they r gonna get away with this...

I paid for the phone, I'm not renting it from them! Its my property, I should be able to do whatever I want with it! I pay them every month to use their network, I should be able to do whatever I want with it....if I bought a tv from best buy they couldn't "take away" the option to turn it off and on simply because I use it to much....the cable company can't "throttle" channels because some ppl watch them to much!

I have no doubt this will come into action soon, and it will be a sad day for the android community

Sent from my Droid

When you buy a gun, its not ok to shoot someone with it. You cannot use your phone to steel teathering. Its a product and it helps create someone's job.
 
Just my thoughts...don't see how they r gonna get away with this...

I paid for the phone, I'm not renting it from them! Its my property, I should be able to do whatever I want with it! I pay them every month to use their network, I should be able to do whatever I want with it....if I bought a tv from best buy they couldn't "take away" the option to turn it off and on simply because I use it to much....the cable company can't "throttle" channels because some ppl watch them to much!

I have no doubt this will come into action soon, and it will be a sad day for the android community

Sent from my Droid

When you buy a gun, its not ok to shoot someone with it. You cannot use your phone to steel teathering. Its a product and it helps create someone's job.

Exactly, further best buy doesn't supply your cable. If you were stealing cable, your cable provider would and could shut you down. I still fail to see how people can realistically argue that tethering is not stealing. Talk about denial. Its amazing

Sent from my Droid using Tapatalk
 
I was specifically told there was a 5GB cap by VZW. Granted, this was almost two years ago... so that may no longer be accurate. That is what I was told though. I have never even gotten close to going over that amount, so I have no idea of the consequences. I was just told that if I didn't go over it, there wouldn't be any problems. And there haven't been.
 
Denial?

I asked VERIZON at the time of my contract, not members of droidforums.net

It's like as a teenager, asking my parents to go to a movie on a weekday and they say "okay, as long as you don't abuse your curfew". Then my brother comes along and says "you can't". I asked my parents if it was okay, I don't care what my brother thinks.

Sorry bros, Dad said it was okay.
 
This would not bother me if Verizon would offer software upgrades and support for devices that are still under contract, but they are not. I got my Droid just over a year ago, and if anything happens with it, I'm SOL. If I didn't root the thing, I'd be rocking a highly underclocked Froyo with no hope of it ever improving, even if the hardware of the phone itself lends it to be much more than they wanted.

They sign you to the contract, then hold back how often your device gets Google upgrades, and then when we find a way around it, they overly crack down to the point where everyone is screwed.

And lets not overlook the fact that Verizon is forcing these locked bootloaders at the same time the iPhone comes. Funny, cause the iPhone gets constant upgrades, and no matter what version you have, you will continuously see improvements until your contract is up.
 
Denial?

I asked VERIZON at the time of my contract, not members of droidforums.net

It's like as a teenager, asking my parents to go to a movie on a weekday and they say "okay, as long as you don't abuse your curfew". Then my brother comes along and says "you can't". I asked my parents if it was okay, I don't care what my brother thinks.

Sorry bros, Dad said it was okay.

Actually I would trust quite a few people here on their word over something a VZW Rep said. One thing is certain, most vzw reps are as in the dark on these issues as we are as consumers.

sent from the great depths of my phones internet (thanks Al Gore)
 
Just my thoughts...don't see how they r gonna get away with this...

I paid for the phone, I'm not renting it from them! Its my property, I should be able to do whatever I want with it! I pay them every month to use their network, I should be able to do whatever I want with it....if I bought a tv from best buy they couldn't "take away" the option to turn it off and on simply because I use it to much....the cable company can't "throttle" channels because some ppl watch them to much!

I have no doubt this will come into action soon, and it will be a sad day for the android community

Sent from my Droid

When you buy a gun, its not ok to shoot someone with it. You cannot use your phone to steel teathering. Its a product and it helps create someone's job.

Exactly, further best buy doesn't supply your cable. If you were stealing cable, your cable provider would and could shut you down. I still fail to see how people can realistically argue that tethering is not stealing. Talk about denial. Its amazing

Sent from my Droid using Tapatalk
How are you stealing something you pay for (data usage) ?
Now if you hacked the network and got data for free (like stealing cable) then you certainly should have to pay . Tethering is not using the network without paying , you are paying for the data . If I flashed a ROM on my Cable box I bought that allowed me to watch through a laptop with a USB cable , am I stealing something I pay for already ? Although I am using the Cable Box outside it's intended purpose the data is paid for every month .
If I break into my own home am I a thief/robber ? NO !
 
Last edited:
Damn I detest control! It I pay for a device I should be allowed to modify as I wish. I'm willing to pay VZW their fees for service why should they or any other carrier care what I change. GO AWAY BIG RED CONTROLS!!!!!!!!!!!
 
Where do you get the 5gb number. Not trying to be a jerk, just trying to understand where the assumptiom of "5 and throttled" is coming from

Sent from my Droid using Tapatalk

5GB was the old 3G Data Card limit. And that's the limit that Verizon set for tethering on 3G phones that could tether. I talked to about 5 reps (in the IT Department) asking them if I could pay for tethering on my Droid 1 because I wanted to tether legally. They said they couldn't add the package to my plan and to just use the market apps for tethering and keep it under 5GB and I'll be ok. That's where 5GB came from because that's what most of Verizon told us Droid 1 users to keep it under if we were tethering.
 
When you buy a gun, its not ok to shoot someone with it. You cannot use your phone to steel teathering. Its a product and it helps create someone's job.

Exactly, further best buy doesn't supply your cable. If you were stealing cable, your cable provider would and could shut you down. I still fail to see how people can realistically argue that tethering is not stealing. Talk about denial. Its amazing

Sent from my Droid using Tapatalk
How are you stealing something you pay for (data usage) ?
Now if you hacked the network and got data for free (like stealing cable) then you certainly should have to pay . Tethering is not using the network without paying , you are paying for the data . If I flashed a ROM on my Cable box I bought that allowed me to watch through a laptop with a USB cable , am I stealing something I pay for already ? Although I am using the Cable Box outside it's intended purpose the data is paid for every month .
If I break into my own home am I a thief/robber ? NO !

You DO NOT pay for unlimited data for anything you want. You pay for unlimited data for one device and one device only. How do people not understand that. The analogies are all just justifications for making yourself feel ok about tethering.

sent from the great depths of my phones internet (thanks Al Gore)
 
I was specifically told there was a 5GB cap by VZW. Granted, this was almost two years ago... so that may no longer be accurate. That is what I was told though. I have never even gotten close to going over that amount, so I have no idea of the consequences. I was just told that if I didn't go over it, there wouldn't be any problems. And there haven't been.

Verizon reps are also notorious for telling people to install Task Killer's to fix their Android phones. ;)
 
You DO NOT pay for unlimited data for anything you want. You pay for unlimited data for one device and one device only. How do people not understand that. The analogies are all just justifications for making yourself feel ok about tethering.

sent from the great depths of my phones internet (thanks Al Gore)

I just wanted everyone to read this. And then read it again. If you're not sure about it, read it one more time. This is absolutely correct.
 
Damn I detest control! It I pay for a device I should be allowed to modify as I wish. I'm willing to pay VZW their fees for service why should they or any other carrier care what I change. GO AWAY BIG RED CONTROLS!!!!!!!!!!!


AMEN Mike!!!!!!!!
 
This would not bother me if Verizon would offer software upgrades and support for devices that are still under contract, but they are not. I got my Droid just over a year ago, and if anything happens with it, I'm SOL. If I didn't root the thing, I'd be rocking a highly underclocked Froyo with no hope of it ever improving, even if the hardware of the phone itself lends it to be much more than they wanted.

They sign you to the contract, then hold back how often your device gets Google upgrades, and then when we find a way around it, they overly crack down to the point where everyone is screwed.

And lets not overlook the fact that Verizon is forcing these locked bootloaders at the same time the iPhone comes. Funny, cause the iPhone gets constant upgrades, and no matter what version you have, you will continuously see improvements until your contract is up.

Please let's not start the iPhone conspiracies. This has nothing to do with that. They are two separate issues. The lack of updates for Droids and WinMo phones on Verizon have been a problem since LONG before Apple was in the picture. Apple does the updates personally. Google does not on Android. Huge difference there.

As far as the reason for rooting and getting your own updates and upgrades, I completely agree with that and that also has been my primary reason. That is also the main reason I want root, I don't trust them for timely upgrades.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top